Recently I published a new review page for CommentLuv Premium (since it’s on sale through October 4, 2011 for over 50% off). I’m a huge fan of the free version, and wrestled with getting the premium version but I bought it for a reason.
You can read my CommentLuv Premium review for those reasons, but here I wanted to lay out my strategy with the plugin.
How to Use CommentLuv Premium on a Niche Site
First, a few important points to make:
- You don’t need to have your comments turned ON to use it.
- You might want to have your comments turned on, but see above.
- This plugin takes the weaknesses of blog commenting and flips them upside-down.
- You can get targeted backlinks with great anchor text through blog commenting.
Really quickly about points 1 and 2 – “you don’t need your comments turned ON/you might want to…” What do I mean?
Essentially, CommentLuv allows your blog commentators to leave a comment that links to one of their last 10 posts. A drop-down menu appears and allows them to choose – and the title of the post is the anchor text.
Excellent for anyone who optimizes their post titles.
It was designed to encourage blog comments, and it works both ways since you go on a blog commenting ‘run’ to get yourself some links on other CommentLuv-enabled blogs.
On most niche-websites, like my own, people don’t want comments turned on. Well, you don’t have to change that if you don’t want. But you may want to.
Advantage of Leaving Comments On
Besides the fact that user-generated content is unique, and it adds to the freshness of your content, giving Google something new to crawl – CommentLuv Premium offers another advantage.
You can choose ‘Perks’ or ‘Incentives’ if you will for your commentators. In the case of this plugin, you can set the following:
- Commentators can be offered to choose from their last 10 posts, IF they meet a condition (# of comments approved, if they socially share your post on Facebook/G+/Twitter, if they register for your site).
- Commentators can be told to get DoFollow links IF they meet certain conditions (same as above – on my blog, you get DoFollow links if you FB LIKE or Google +1 my posts).
- Commentators will have a profile that shows if you allow it when people hover over their links, further incentive for people to follow their links.
The implications of being shared socially translate into potential viral traffic. Say for example, someone with a lot of friends were to share your posts on Facebook.
One person in particular does this time to time, Griz – and every time he does this on my blog, I notice it with more traffic, free ebook downloads, sales, etc.
Thanks, Griz!
He has plenty of influence online, even the President of the United States asks his advice in search optimization and social media matters.*
The same is true, if not moreso, with Google +1′s: thanks to personal search. For a while Google has been using social signals to influence the search listings so those in your personal network will change your “top 10 in Google” with their recommendations.
If you can get enough people with large networks (or even if they just have the “right people” in their small networks) to +1 your content, then you can start to see an impact with more traffic.
So here on my blog, I’ve left comments open (of course) and I’m experimenting on my niche sites.
Worried About Spam? Naw
Just in case you thought spam would be an issue, Andy Bailey is the developer of my favorite and most effective spam plugin I’ve used: Growmap Anti-Spam Plugin, or G.A.S.P. Dave hates it (a sure sign he’s spamming me! lol)…and Andy’s behind CommentLuv.
He packaged that plugin in with this one, so you only need one plugin for your spam worries. Not only does the G.A.S.P. plugin work wonders to cut down on spam, the incentives for getting approved comments help, too.
Like: “get X number of approved comments for your last 10 posts to choose from” or for a DoFollow link (whatever you decide).
There’s 2 more incentives to blog comment on ComLuv blogs.
1) You can leave your Twitter username on a Premium CommentLuv blog, so you can grow your Twitter following.
2) The blog owner has the option to include the “Kewyord Name” function (like KeywordLuv) – so when you leave a comment, you get your preferred anchor text by filling out “Your Name@Your Keyword” in the “name” field (I have this turned on, by the way).
Enough about the plugin, though (but you better get it before the price skyrockets – it’s over 50% off here until October 4th).
The Simple Commenting Strategy for Marketers
So I’ve introduced the plugin, now how does it help internet marketers? What if you want your “blog” to have comments turned off?
That’s up to you – I think you should re-consider that because of the incentives to share your content and get you more traffic and backlinks that matter.
Here’s my strategy:
- Visit Ana Hoffman’s “directory” of PR2+ CommentLuv enabled blogs.
- Use relevant blogs there to comment to my niche sites.
- Because I have the premium plugin, I always can choose from 10 most recent posts AND/OR 5 additional posts or PAGES. Otherwise you’re beholden to limitations set by the blog owner.
- Because of that, I’ll leave comments to my product reviews.
- Find other CommentLuv ‘target’ blogs by searching for the footprint: “This blog uses premium CommentLuv” or “premium CommentLuv + keywords” etc.
- Make a list of these blogs and sort according to PageRank but more importantly according to their “signs of life.” Are there 15+ comments per post? Do they have other signs of “social proof” like Twitter, Facebook likes and followers?
- Add these blogs to an RSS reader specific to that niche. I’ll do this using various email accounts and readers to keep organized.
- Whenever I publish new content, go on a CommentLuv commenting run using both Ana’s list and my own private list.
- Use the commenting strategy to build rapport with highly trafficked blogs and write guest posts where it counts.
- Always comment using an HMA Proxy ($11 a month or so, or $50 something every 6 months). This is especially useful if using any directory like Ana’s public directory (I don’t want people seeing my IP address and putting 2 and 2 together). HMA is the cheapest and one of the most effective proxy services I’ve used.
I bought the plugin so of course I think it was worth the $40 price – especially considering this is over 50% off, so expect to pay $97-$197 after October 4th.

In my linking strategy, I’m going to be using the daylights out of this plugin, I’ve already seen how it gets traffic to this blog – add in to the mix preferred anchor text (or at least links to the preferred pages/reviews), potential viral traffic and links from social networks, then it’s a wise investment.
The segue from blog commenting to guest posting is something I think too many people overlook – it works if you’re smart about your target blogs (and not many of your competitors will bother).
Get it before the 4th right here. Or get it after the 4th (I won’t complain). Thanks for dropping by!
*maybe this part might not be true about the president. BUT it could be true, only secret.
Like this post? Subscribe to my RSS feed and get loads more!









Testing CommentLuv Premium.
Trying duct tape url in the comment form
Andrew Bailey recently posted..Are You Using Duct Tape SEO?
Nicely done – thanks again, Andy!
okay… I think you guys ALMOST have me convinced to get this. Too bad I only have 2 more days to decide before the price goes up. I have a couple questions for you.
1. So you don’t know what the actual final price will be?
2. I have been doing a similar strategy in the last few days of finding high PR blogs in my niche that use comment or keywordluv, subscribing to them, I set up a separate folder for their emails, and then I comment on them as I have time. As a commentor I LOVE using commentluv premium, but I’ve been wondering about the regular commentluv – aside rom some new content, is there a reason why it would be beneficial to webmasters? Which, I realize, is a bit offtopic, but just a curiosity.
3. Why do you recommend using a proxy server? I’m not sure what that does.
4. What’s the process using it on multiple sites? Do you have to buy extra licenses or do you just install the plugin like any other plugin?
Thank you!
Bethany recently posted..Black Friday / Cyber Monday 2011 Ukulele Deals
I know, I was late in getting the plugin myself. I didn’t want to get it if it would only be used here at the Average Genius, I wanted it for my other sites, too – where I’m ghost-writing my own content. I try to keep a low profile in my niche sites, so that’s why I use a proxy server…
Let me answer you in order:
1. Not sure if it’s going to be $97 or $197, I didn’t bother asking Andy Bailey and I’m not sure he’s decided yet, either. But I do know $40 is less than 50% of $97. :)
2. The free CommentLuv allows you to get social proof, encourage comments and give a little back to your commentators, that’s about it really. So I liked it for those reasons here.
3. A proxy server masks your IP address, so in the server logs or in the admin panel of the blogs where you leave a comment, the webmaster and sometimes guest posters can see your IP address, and it only matters to paranoid types like me who want to be anonymous. I may leave 2 different comments from 2 of my sites on a blog – but I don’t want the webmaster to know they’re both my websites necessarily. The HMA proxy masks your true IP address to various countries of your choosing.
4. To use it on multiple sites, you simply upload it like normal and check your password/username you’re given with the license.
Hope that helps – and SMART of you to have your Black Friday/Cyber Monday stuff up….
okay that makes a lot of sense. Commentluv makes sense on personal blogs and stuff like that but I didn’t really see how it benefits niche sites themselves aside from a way to “give back.” And new content. I think it was mostly puzzling to me because when I was looking for comment/keywordluv blogs this week, nearly ALL the keywordluv logs I found were niche sites, and I was looking for personal blogs. It just made me wonder… what’s the benefit to them? The only logical thing I could think of was that the niche blog webmasters are marketers, so they know the value of a properly SEO’d text link, but most bloggers have no idea so wouldn’t even think to go there. I did find a pretty decent amount of commentluv though, and a couple commentluv premium blogs as well.
I have the free plugin on my blog, and I think it does help although a lot of my regular commenters are not really catching on, I think. But that’s just a personal blog, no marketing on it, so that might be why. I am very tempted to get it… will just have to keep ruminating on that. Been trying to save up my marketing income for a restock order on my bestselling Amazon product (I’m also an Amazon seller) and I need to get that done before the Holiday rush starts.
And thanks on the black friday thing :) I did it now because I wanted to see if I can get the page ranked ahead of time… not a whole lot of traffic but I figured I’d take advantage of what there will be.
Bethany recently posted..Black Friday / Cyber Monday 2011 Ukulele Deals
Well, well well! A seller, too – that just goes to show how much money I leave on the table. I’m insanely interested in how that compares to affiliate marketing – you’d have to really know your margins, but thinking over just some eBay one-off sales I’ve done, I can see there’s real money in that.
Can I read your story somewhere about how that’s going?
By the way, I’m about to email you for your question on the book (I just realized who I was speaking to!) and I think / hope I have an answer.
James. I agree and have already gotten CL Premium. I also wholeheartedly recommend it for any fence sitters.
You skipped one of my FAVORITE features too. With CL premium others have the option of leaving 1 dofollow link. Set it up the right way and they can choose from a list of posts BUT only if they FB Like, Google + or Tweet your post.
It is a nice social deal when you think about it. You are giving them a dofollow link, they are making sure others find your link (and SEO wise ensuring that link if fractionally more valuable)
Steve recently posted..How to Prevent a “Red Sox Collapse” with your Internet Business
That’s one of my favorite settings – to be able to get a DoFollow link (with anchor text, no less?). The really cool thing is that it’s a win/win – the host blog gets more comments, in the meantime the commentator gets a link he/she wants for engaging. Almost done with your book, Steve – WOW. Really, homerun there!
Thanks for publishing this. #3 gives me a real reason to consider buying the premium version. I have been wondering what the big deal is. I like the free version well enough for my sites, but being able to choose the post to link to on all CommentLuv blogs would sure be a nice perk.
Beth Parker recently posted..Practical Gifts for People with Diabetes
That’s one of the main reasons I’m going to be using it – and don’t overlook Ana Hoffman’s project. I’m sure if you look you can find other CommentLuv blogs in your niche with PR as well – and those targeted deep links make a difference.
I think the plugin sounds interesting but I have to admit I hate the GASP plugin too and get mildly annoyed whenever I see it :P (very annoyed if my comment disappears!)
Aside from that, though, the plugin sounds useful, though I’m not sold yet (better decide quick!). But I am going to link to my mega PLR guide post, thank you very much :)
Ruth recently posted..Fear: False Evidence Appearing Real
Lol I am stupid – didn’t change my post link!!
Ruth recently posted..Everything I Know About Making Money Selling PLR Articles (My Ultimate Guide)
Naw. You just wanted 2 links – you’re smart. :D
JamestheJust recently posted..13 Tips For Making Money by Making Time
Lol, any other blog and they would have deleted my comments for spam ;)
Ruth recently posted..Everything I Know About Making Money Selling PLR Articles (My Ultimate Guide)
You’re welcome… Can’t help Obama though…
Griz recently posted..113 Golf Games Later…
Can’t argue with that.
James Hussey recently posted..Recommended Tools
Random comment so that I can see what you are talking about!
lissie recently posted..2011 Kindle – Kindle Reader, Kindle Touch – Free Kindle eBooks are Going to Be Hot in 2012
Ta-daaa!
JamestheJust recently posted..Rather Genius Blog Posts 1
James, I still am not sure how ComLuv brought traffic to your site BEFORE all these social bribes? was it because other people on other peoples sites saw your link title back to your site in the comments section on other sites?
Exactly – people on ComLuv sites would see the titles to my posts and come to the blog to read more.
Not sure I understand no. 10 right. WHat exactly do you mean by that?
Pam recently posted..Mitgehangen, mitgefangen
Basically I use a proxy server when commenting to my niche websites. This simply hides my IP address so the blog owner can’t see my IP address is the same and then connect the dots.
“Oh, it’s James, he owns the Average Genius AND this other site here, AND that site there….”
So I hide my IP address through HideMyAss (HMA for short), a cheap but effective proxy server that changes my IP address randomly.
JamestheJust recently posted..CommentLuv Premium Strategy and Sale
Okay, I have to fire up HMA and start commenting with my niche sites. If you see a bunch of “nice post” comments, just leave them.
J/K
Carrie recently posted..My Summer Recap
I approved 2 such comments, almost did a 3rd just because of your comment! Ah, well. Sucker’s born every day. Sometimes all it takes is for a “friend” to go all spammy and the flood gates open up.
Thank you, Carrie, for making me a sucka.
BY THE WAY:
NICE thread on Squidoo at the Pond!
I like how you act like you don’t know what you’re doing. I learned some new tips there – right smart ideas.
Great post. Am i too late or is it still available?
Still available – and the developer just added a new bonus – his WP Mail Ads plugin which sells for $27, pretty cool too, I was going to buy it but decided against it. Anyway, if you have a blog where comments get mailed to the commentators (like “Subscribe to Comments” plugins) then you can ad a text ad to that email.
Just 1-2 sales and it’s more than worth it – but it’s now a bonus plugin.
Great post, thank you for sharing it. :)
I let it slide this time just because. :D
Hey James, doing the same as you, been putting Ana’s list to good use since I got CL Premium. Surprised I haven’t “bumped into you” yet!
Still waiting to see more visitors leaving comments, though my blog is only PR1 so maybe that’s got something to do with it…
Ross Taylor recently posted..Blogs Can Give a Boost to Your Onsite SEO
I need to work with you on something – including that guest post. :D Family visiting screwed up me schedule (in a good way). BUT I’d like to see you get more action. I haven’t begun linking YET, but I will – I’ve laid out my strategy so right now it’s content mode.
Beginning my linking with internal links first to keep Panda Bear happy, and increase the UX I think it’s called (User’s Experience – do I have that right?). But for my Duct Tape SEO site, this is my strategy fo sho’ (and I need some linkie link love for this site – might as well, I fell off the habit of commenting).
For my niche sites, I’ll be coming up with a list of ComLuv sites that are niche-related and I have ONE HECK of a resource I’ll be sharing for backlink building this week…good times. (New to ME but not sure if I’m the only one who’s just found it – still, it’s a good resource.)
BTW did you join the Pond? Just curious. The place is actually turning out to be pretty bangin. :D
I think if you DID or WILL join, you should share your Local SEO tips…just sayin.
I came here to learn more about CommentLuv Premium. I have still few hours to byu it for special price. But I need more info whether to buy it or not. I almost made my decision to buy it, but I have few hours time to consider it again.
FinnBlogger recently posted..Kun bloggaaminen ei maistunut
I just received an email where Andy says he’s extending the offer because he wants to do another video and split-test an email relevant to the launch of his new premium plugin – so he’s just extended it another day.
He’s an honest enough fellow – not sure if this was “planned” but the plugin itself is worth it. Whether you buy from me or not isn’t the point, you should really consider buying the plugin for your own business, it’s an honest value-add to anyone building links online.
I’ve followed your blog for a while with great interest, and now I had an opportunity to say “thank you” by buying CommentLuv through your link. Actually, your ideas presented above were much better at pre-selling than the actual CommentLuv site – good job.
I was also running the free version before, so I’m really eager to try the new features.
Thanks a ton for that, Marcin – really appreciate the comment and sale. I’m stoked to hear it! (I’m especially stoked Andy’s made all these crazy improvements to the plugin, guy’s crazy good.)
Really enjoy the CommentLuv Premium plugin, it has so many great features. I do however miss the ComLuv search engine where you can easily find other CommentLuv blogs :)
Justin Germino recently posted..Amazon Silk Browser Tracks Everything You Do
I miss that, too. But I haven’t put away all my old bag of tricks quite yet. I have a few tools to make that easier – luckily Google’s pretty good at finding these links, too.
Hey James,
I have to say, CL premium is my first and only paid plugin. I have been using the free version for a long time and when Andy announced that he was going to work on updating it and making it even better, I knew I would buy it.
I love the fact that it does the job of 7 other plugins all at once and that means Faster blog!
Satrap recently posted..61 Easy And Free Ways To Increase Website Traffic
True – I forgot to mention that but it’s pretty efficient!
I just installed CommentLuv Premium and now I am reading reviews how to use it more effectively.
FinnBlogger recently posted..Kun bloggaaminen ei maistunut
Oh wow, I’ve been told to comment on the blogs that has a commentluv plugin but honestly, I never know what’s the advantage aside from your last blog will be displayed.
barrie recently posted..Revitol Eye Cream Review
I have premium CommentLuv and I just love it. I found out that I can add a list of old posts (or pages!) to use as the list of posts from which I can select when commenting (NOT just my latest posts). It actually gives me a choice of 15 articles to promote, including landing pages.
AstroGremlin recently posted..You Don’t Know Your Best Ideas
Yeah, it’s pretty boss – but I see it only allows 10 posts period. I thought it was 15 (only on your home blog it seems?) – but choosing the 5 pages/posts of your choice is still solid (even if it’s “only” 10 total).
Hello James,
So far I am liking it. The CommentLuv Plug-in is pretty awesome.
Thank you for posting such great information. I love your blog.
Will visit here often.
Cheers!
Amy
Amy Hewitt recently posted..Email Marketing Course
Amy –
Do you have the premium version of it? If not, I’m giving away a copy in a drawing. Will be announcing that soon.
CommentLuv has a lot of success, especially nowadays, since CommentLuv Premium has been launched, there are a lot of posts and articles everywhere about CommentLuv, I think they’ve hit the big jackpot. Indeed, CommentLuv Premium is very useful and brings a lot of backlinks and creates connections between bloggers and websites. Thanks for the strategy sale exposed, really cool!
Amit recently posted..Finding Forklift Training And Certification For Free
This seems like a great feature for both the commentators and for the site/blog owner. Visitors that add value to the site will basically get a link back to their site. This should definitely cut down the spam levels.