So the book is largely done, with the graphics being worked on and some peer review being conducted at present…and I can’t wait to hear the feedback. I’ll tell you what, though – I’m going through my own 301 Redirect here…
In case you don’t know, a 301 Redirect is a detour sign for search engines, directing traffic to the new home of whatever content you were reaching for – and I’m feeling pretty 301-ish.
In writing this book and in researching the daylights out of the topic of SEO for anyone interested (WordPress SEO in particular), I’ve been doing some experimenting with websites that frankly have done very well in search. They ranked and ranked just fine, thanks.
I didn’t use the normal link building frenzy that I’ve been well-groomed to do. No fancy software, nothing – though by now I own an arsenal of tools many would envy.
I’m thinking over my priorities, my identity in this niche, my direction – and it’s one thing when you’re a freelancer learning the ropes and your clients come to the table with ideas…you sort of go along for the ride. Do as you’re told. They pay you to sling links, or spin articles, slug it out…and you figure, “This voodoo works.”
Well, it did. It worked / works. Get links, then rank – it’s not a secret. But honestly I’m taking stock of the same old game and wonder if I’ve just been duped…
I’m looking on my hard-drive and wondering why it looks like I own stock in Clickbank.
I’ve been in sales really since I learned how to talk – persuading my parents that yes, I needed another helping at the dinner table, or yes, I needed the ‘new Atari 2600′ with the paddle controls, too. Hard to play Breakout when you just had the joystick with that one red button…
Something like that. It’s part of who I am: convince and convert.
But I’m telling you, writing this book and then retracing my steps – I think I’ve been sold on SEO “shortcuts” so long I never thought there was any other way around the SERPs. Literally, I’m staring at them just under my post editor, in the status bar. On my desktop is every flavor of submitter, I haven’t even talked about them all here yet.
And that’s always the plan, by the way – buy a tool, use it, write about it and sell it. Break even and then some. By the way, thank you all for using my affiliate links, I honestly appreciate it…and at the same time, I wonder what happened to my own sales resistance along the way.
Do you know I don’t own Magic S.ubmitter because I own every other submitter there is? My wife asked me that one day and I didn’t have a good answer why I still “needed” to pay a monthly fee for M. Submitter – she was right. I have every submitter a kid could want.
Yipee.
So what that means is: I don’t need to pay a monthly fee to do what everyone in my niche is trained to do by software developers and fellow IMers, which is to sling links to slug it out for top rankings. “Everyone’s doing it, I can’t get ahead if I don’t…” Right?
So on a lark, I made a decision with this book to experiment. I’ve been duped.
The idea hasn’t been too far from me for some time now, to be honest. Now before you think I’m saying those tools don’t work – I’m not saying that. What I am saying is that I’m wresting with this idea of need. Are these tools necessary? How hard is it to rank without using them?
You might notice I’ve taken a ton of product-related links off my sidebar.
I’m going to be weighing things out carefully in how I proceed from now on, and since I don’t want to spoil my own book (because I’d like to sell it), I’ll just say this: ranking a website doesn’t take automated link building.
No, really. I’ve seen the other side of the coin here in my own network – and it didn’t really shock me all that much. I’ll have to run my own tests, of course – but the gig’s tired. I don’t mean “affiliate marketing,” but I mean the, “must have mass submission tools” approach is tired.
So I’m at a 301 Redirect of my own.
Granted, link building isn’t ethical. Period. But – neither is telling the world that automated link building is “the only way to compete.” Nor is it the best way to compete.
Writing this book is something of a career change – and it’s the book I wish I was given when I started out. Honestly, it was eye-opening, ranking these recent sites, and refreshing to boot.
I hope to do a case study on it proper just to show you all what I mean. Needless to say, my experiments are the heart of the book, and the book’s been a long time in coming.
When the dust settles and I can get this book published (putting up my sales page, thank you page, getting graphics figured out, all that, but it’s written and ready), I’ll need to do some hard thinking about the direction of this blog. As it sits, I’m not exactly sure right now.
On the one hand: link-building works, period – on the other hand…hm. Yeah. It’s in the book. Right now I have two identities – my practical side which says, “This works, why change?” and the old man living inside me that says, “This isn’t the only or best way to conduct business online…”
What I’m specifically talking about is how I’ve been taught link-building largely by my Elance clients and also my fellow bloggers. No – not taking a swipe at anyone here, I’m just thinking out loud at how I’ve been trained to think a certain way.
Now I’m trying other methods and surprised they work as “advertised.”
Suffice it to say I got off on the wrong foot in this business, and couldn’t be convinced otherwise. I had to see and test things for myself…and what I’ve found is something a lot more worthwhile, rewarding and stable than what I’ve been sold to believe.
I’m not pointing fingers at people, by the way – I think we’ve all just been sold on the shortcuts so long we think there’s no alternative. That’s bullshit.
Sometimes in the course of the English language, nothing cuts to the quick faster than dropping all eloquence and calling a cow pattie some bullshit. There, I said it.
I think rising above the noise on the net isn’t going to be easy to do, but it’s time to cut the crap and aim for something a bit higher. Look, if you want to sling links, spin articles and do the same thing everyone is trained to do: I can’t blame you.
Been there, done that and so has everyone else – the links you get will be as cheap and dirty and easy to replicate as your competitors, assuming they don’t report you for webspam through Google Webmaster Tools. Also assuming the algorithm never changes…
Google gets smarter…a competitor fires off a complaint to Google…a new filter is introduced…it’s a tired game of cat and mouse. Maybe it’s one thing to get a site knocked off the index when it was making $50 a month, but you have 300 others to replace it…
But your whole network de-indexed? It’s not “news,” it happens. Or what if your whole living exists on one or two websites and they take a beating? Same deal. Food for thought…if it sounds like I’m wrestling with this idea – I am.
I’ve been sold, then turned around and sold you – all without testing to see if rankings are possible without all these gimmicks…would you believe me if I told you it’s much easier than you’ve been told?
Sure, it takes work, but it’s still easier than you think. Surprisingly, I’ve found a method that results in needing far fewer links than I thought possible. Wrote a book on it. :)
Stay tuned. Thanks for readin’.
Like this post? Subscribe to my RSS feed and get loads more!








Now you got me curious…
Great way to promote a book :)
Thanks, Shawn – it’s not a promotional gimmick, but I’m sure it could seem that way. It’s just a candid look at where I’m at. Cheers!
Good stuff James,
I hear where you are coming from. There is no doubt that link building is still extremely important, but there are now a lot more factors coming in to play. I know we both still have quite different approaches but I get the feeling that we are all kind of converging to the same place.
And the new direction a lot of people are now taking, me included, may be a bit more of a waiting game but the end results are going to be a lot more permanent.
Man, all this is kind of esoteric isn’t it?
What are they talking about, I hear people say.
Good luck with the book James.
Dave recently posted..Anatomy
It is funny how Panda slaps do that to you (me, I mean). Dave, over the past 2 years, yours has been one of the most real and inspirational blogs on the planet – so thanks for taking the time to drop a line. I appreciate your friendship, anti-social though you insist you are (I don’t believe you).
Best of luck on your book sales, too – I read your book and wanted to pack it in. But we’re just totally different people in how we approach things. I read yours and thought, “Oh, the last person I want to compete with…”
Funny how we wrote on largely the same subject. I hope your sales kick break records, my friend.
I have these types of feelings myself as I go back and see what has and hasn’t worked over the last 2+ years. I wasted a lot of timing setting up sites based on shortcut methods but had I just repeated what I did with my very first site in 2005 (when I knew very little), I’d probably be a lot farther than I am.
I am planning to start a new site or two in the next few months and will be trying a similar path to what you suggest. It actually feels better to go that way because I am going for niches I like and just organizing the sites in a way that makes sense.
:)
Carrie recently posted..My July Earnings – Phew!
It’s funny, too because my wife’s got a couple of blogs at present and I don’t want to touch them. I just want her audience to grow based on her merits as a writer, her participation in that community of bloggers or whatever.
The difficulty is that I know this all works. I know that spinning and submitting articles still works – but then I read other places like ProBlogger or CopyBlogger, SmartPassiveIncome and ViperChill…OK, maybe Pat’s an exception with his UAW usage, but by and large they don’t use these methods I’ve been trained on (and they’re all doing 6-figures).
Somewhere along the line I missed that memo. I probably should’ve read “Cloud Blogging” by Glen or something early on, but old habits are hard to break. Hopefully it goes well on your new ventures, Carrie.
So basically through the process of writing an entire book, it’s made you rethink the approach you’ve been using for years? Its interesting how that can happen when you spend weeks upon weeks working on one major project :-)
Well, that and then some. I’ve been having reservations about the process used to rank websites, with the amount of emails I get and the same questions along the lines of, “Which submitter is best? What would I do if I couldn’t *afford* Magic Submitter or Article Marketing Robot? etc.”
Then I stopped using the tools to run an experiment or three and my rankings are just fine. I’m sure it depends on the niche, on the competition, etc. – but getting to the top on links anyone can replicate isn’t a fortified position, and let’s be honest: you need links, but you don’t need every single tool I have, or even most of the tools I have.
This book about summarizes my observations on the direction I’m heading, and why – but it’s not an autobiography. It’s a book on WordPress SEO.
That’s interesting. I’m largely invested in automation right now. I’m interested in seeing what it is you have up your sleeve. I think higher quality links take more time to get, but are worth far more. Lower qualities are easy to snag and easy to automate. It all depends on Goog’s approach. We all know what direction it’s headed though. I’m starting up a private network soon enough to dodge some of this.
Well, I want to be careful here because yes: I have an ebook that’s based on a new system, step-by-step described and not dependent on my usual suspects. Anyone invested in automating can still benefit from the system, but this new direction isn’t going to be temporary for me. I think quality over quantity is stated so much it loses its impact – but you point out the practical matter: it is easier to spam links.
So will I convince anyone not to continue down that road? Well, I hope it at least gets people thinking about the broader picture, but that’s not really my goal. I’ve sold plenty of tools and subscriptions here (ok, not some stellar amount to be honest, but I’ve made my money back and then some)…and I no longer want to participate in the selling of the endless supply of tools.
(I wouldn’t need any more anyway, my goodness – I have it all.)
What I don’t want to do is say one method works while the other doesn’t, but it’s always been in Google’s best interests to fight what we do on a normal basis. Their posture, both officially and matter-of-factly hasn’t been friendly to the ranking gig…so I think these methods are simply on borrowed time. That’s conjecture, but I think it’s coming.
At the same time, hey: don’t let me stop you. I’m not the link sheriff and don’t want to be – I’m just tired of the cat-and-mouse with my (not play money) livelihood hanging in the balance.
Hey there James, have you considered turning your feelings into a live case study for your blog? Heck, I wouldn’t mind joining you in something like that (e.g. no automation tools, no forum profiles, no mass article submissions, no junk directories, etc) and sharing my website, link bait strategies, etc with you. That could be a new “niche site duel,” minus the funny looking (and scary/spammy) link wheel strategies. :)
Yolanda recently posted..Closed Indefinitely…Because I Was Wrong and I Intend to Stop Adding Junk to the Web
Sounds like a plan – now I just need to figure out which site to use. Give me time after the launch, though – I think it would be best to put it up on the book’s site (I bought a domain for it)…the skeeery thing is knowing your over achieving self.
I could go down in flames…and I don’t normally fight girls. Women, I mean. But I might just have to break that rule this once. (Hope your husband doesn’t read that.)
JamestheJust recently posted..A Career 301 Redirect – In Between Worlds Here
Well then it’s a plan Stan! Actually, it will also force me to start adding some more content to my blog. I might as well get my monies worth since I renewed the domain. :)
Also, instead of a fight, I’ll consider it to be a healthy ranking competition/accountability and strategy sharing opportunity and I intend to start from scratch with a domain that I’ll register either tonight or by Monday. (I’m sitting on two domains for this niche that have been registered for almost a year, however, they’re still too broad). I know I’ll make my money back once the website gains some traction so I don’t feel as though I threw too much money down the drain.
Shoot me a private email when you get some down time regarding the launch. I’ll most likely plug your e-book into the case study since you’ll be basing any SEO you perform off of it.
Yep. I should’ve kept my mouth shut. :)
Ah- it’ll be fun. I’ve been reading more Pat Flynn lately and don’t think a bit of transparency would kill me.
Love this idea!
Ruth recently posted..Having A Goal And Making It Happen
I love the idea of traveling. There. We’re even. :)
This is definitely a 180 on your part. I never really got into automated tools (bought article marketing robot but never used it & didn’t like SE Nuke). I’m looking forward to your new book as I am now really starting to look at this more long term instead of just now or a few months from now. I want my sites to still be bringing me in money 10 years down the road.
Tiffany recently posted..My Thesis Theme Review and Why I Use It On Most of My Websites
Tiffany – it is a 180, I’m hoping that anyone who tries the method finds it a refreshing take on the same problem of getting traffic and rankings, but the methods of link building bring instant traffic regardless of ranking. I think we get so focused on certain methods (like article submission) that we (I) tend to forget that instant traffic gratification isn’t a myth – it goes hand in hand with link quality.
(That’s the best part about the method, besides the rankings – getting an audience before ranking is always a plus.)
I’m so embarrassed. I JUST noticed the image for this post.
Love it :)
Carrie recently posted..My July Earnings – Phew!
You should be – they had to put a sign out just for YOU? Shame. What were you doing wreaking all that havoc?
I was out there with my ray gun trying to control the situation.
Carrie recently posted..My July Earnings – Phew!
Should’ve used the Wunderwaffe DG-2.
JamestheJust recently posted..A Career 301 Redirect – In Between Worlds Here
Now I have to say you have me very curious. I’ll definitely be staying tuned in to see what you’ve learned through your experiments.
I’m probably like yourself, been trying to find non-traditional ways to rank and get traffic, not sold on traditional link building … but then, I’m a “novice” at this so I read and learn.
I guess it depends on what you mean by ‘traditional’ – but I’ve results from the methods I’ve espoused here on the blog. The thing that’s grating about it is that little voice that says you don’t need all these tools…I’ve just been so groomed to use software to build links I never tried otherwise.
Best of luck to you, Barry.
Now you’ve got me interested. I might just have to buy that book.
Beth Parker recently posted..Stuart Weitzman 5050 Boots on Sale
Hope you enjoy it, Beth.